Mac and office · sound
Membrane keyboard
test de son.
The Dell, HP, or Lenovo board that came with the desk — the most common keyboard on earth, and the one with the least going on. Press play to hear what it could sound like instead.
Écouter
What a Membrane keyboard
en pratique.
Chaque bouton joue une courte phrase enregistrée avec cette famille de switchs. Vous pouvez ainsi comparer le rythme plutôt qu’une seule frappe. Écoutez deux options à la suite : la différence devient plus nette.
Ces extraits correspondent à la famille de switchs, pas à ce clavier précis. Les options peuvent varier selon l’année et la région : vérifiez la version qui vous intéresse.
Ce que vous entendez
Son caractère
sonne vraiment.
A membrane keyboard has a rubber dome under every key sitting on a printed plastic sheet. Pressing the key collapses the dome, which completes the circuit and provides all of the resistance you feel. There is no mechanism, no separate contact, and nothing designed to produce a sound.
So what you hear is the keycap hitting the plate and the dome collapsing under it — a dull, slightly muddy thud with a rubbery edge to it. Full-size office boards are usually large hollow plastic trays, which adds a cheap ring behind the thud, and the wide keys often rattle because the stabilisers are loose.
The characteristic problem is not volume but definition. A membrane board makes noise; it just does not make an informative noise. Every key sounds broadly the same, the sound arrives after you have already bottomed out, and there is nothing at all on the release.
Pourquoi il sonne comme ça
Sa construction
derrière le bruit.
Rubber domes on a membrane sheet in a hollow plastic tray, which is the cheapest possible way to build a keyboard and the reason the design is still everywhere. Because the dome does double duty as both the spring and the switch, there is no way to tune the feel and the sound independently — anything that makes the board quieter also makes it mushier. This is the construction that mechanical switches exist to replace.
- Mechanism
- Rubber dome over a membrane sheet
- Travel
- Typically 3.5 to 4 mm
- Case
- Hollow plastic tray
- Keycaps
- Thin ABS
Même catégorie
Autres claviers
de cette catégorie.
Ou consultez notre sélection de 51 claviers populaires associés à un son, puis ouvrez le labo sonore du clavier pour essayer les huit sons sur votre propre clavier.
Par switch
Ou explorez
par switch.
Si vous hésitez déjà entre deux switchs, les pages dédiées vont plus loin que celle d’un seul clavier : elles proposent les mêmes enregistrements, les caractéristiques publiées par Cherry, une explication du mécanisme et des conseils pour choisir.
Emportez-le partout
Vous aimez ce son ?
sur votre Mac ?
Cette page ne produit du son que tant que l'onglet est actif. TypeLouder joue les mêmes enregistrements dans toutes vos applications — éditeur, terminal ou messagerie — avec le clavier que vous possédez déjà, sur vos haut-parleurs ou dans votre casque.
Elle ne lit ni ne stocke jamais vos frappes, et n'a aucun accès réseau.
Obtenir TypeLouder — $2.99 une seule foismacOS 15.5 ou version ultérieure · sans abonnement
Bonnes questions
Membrane keyboard
en questions.
Can a membrane keyboard sound like a mechanical one?
Not physically — the mechanism that makes the sound simply is not there, and nothing you can do to a rubber dome will produce a click or a tactile bump. In software it is straightforward: a sound app plays a recorded mechanical switch on every keystroke, which is a much bigger improvement here than on a keyboard that already has some character of its own.
Why does my office keyboard sound rattly?
Usually the stabilisers on the wide keys — Space, Enter, Shift, Backspace. Those keys need a wire bar underneath to keep them level, and on cheap boards the bar is loose in its housings and free to buzz on every press. It is the single most audible flaw on a budget membrane keyboard and it gets worse as the board ages.
Is a membrane keyboard worse than a mechanical one?
For sound and feedback, clearly. For everything else it is more of a trade than people admit: membrane boards are cheaper, lighter, quieter in absolute terms, and often more spill-resistant. If the sound and the feel are what you care about, a mechanical board is a real upgrade — and if only the sound is, an app gets you most of the way for a fraction of the money.
Les sons de cette page proviennent de packs enregistrés par la communauté et utilisés sous la licence MIT. They are recordings of the switch family, not of a Generic membrane office keyboard specifically. All product and brand names are trademarks of their respective owners; this page is not affiliated with or endorsed by them.